Top 10 Indianapolis Spots for Afternoon Drinks You Can Trust

Indianapolis isn’t just the heart of the Hoosier State—it’s a thriving hub of flavor, culture, and community, especially when the afternoon sun casts a golden glow over its streets. Whether you’re winding down from a morning of meetings, catching up with a friend, or simply seeking a quiet moment with a well-crafted beverage, the right spot can transform an ordinary hour into something memorable. But not all afternoon drink destinations are created equal. In a city brimming with options, trust becomes the deciding factor. Trust in consistency. Trust in quality. Trust in ambiance that feels genuine, not manufactured. This guide reveals the top 10 Indianapolis spots for afternoon drinks you can truly trust—places where the drinks are expertly made, the staff remembers your name, and the atmosphere invites you to stay awhile.

Why Trust Matters

In an era where social media filters and viral trends often overshadow substance, finding a place that delivers authentic value is more important than ever. When it comes to afternoon drinks, trust isn’t just about the taste of your cocktail or the freshness of your coffee—it’s about the entire experience. It’s the barista who knows you prefer oat milk without being asked. It’s the bartender who pours your favorite whiskey with the same care every time. It’s the quiet corner table that’s always available, even on busy Saturdays.

Trust is built over time, through repeated positive experiences. A spot that earns your trust doesn’t need flashy signage or celebrity endorsements. It thrives on word-of-mouth, repeat visitors, and a commitment to excellence that doesn’t waver with the seasons. In Indianapolis, where local pride runs deep, the most trusted venues are often those rooted in community—family-owned, independently operated, and deeply connected to the neighborhoods they serve.

Afternoon drinks are more than a refreshment—they’re a ritual. A pause. A moment of clarity. And that moment deserves to be spent somewhere reliable. Whether you’re sipping a crisp local lager, savoring a slow-brewed cold brew, or enjoying a hand-muddled gin & tonic, the setting should enhance the drink, not distract from it. The places featured in this guide have been selected not for their Instagram appeal, but for their enduring reputation, consistent quality, and genuine hospitality. These are the spots where Indianapolis residents return, week after week, season after season.

Top 10 Indianapolis Spots for Afternoon Drinks

1. The Varsity Club

Nestled in the heart of downtown Indianapolis, The Varsity Club is a hidden gem that has quietly earned a devoted following since its opening in 2017. Housed in a restored 1920s building, the space blends classic Midwestern charm with modern sophistication. The afternoon menu is curated for leisure—think hand-squeezed citrus cocktails, local craft sodas, and an extensive selection of Indiana-brewed lagers and pilsners.

What sets The Varsity Club apart is its unwavering commitment to seasonal ingredients. Their signature “Afternoon Spritz,” made with locally foraged elderflower, house-made ginger syrup, and a splash of dry sparkling wine, changes subtly with each season. The staff, many of whom have worked there for over five years, know regulars by name and remember their preferences without prompting. The outdoor patio, shaded by mature trees and lined with vintage string lights, offers a serene escape from the city bustle. It’s the kind of place where time slows down—and you don’t mind letting it.

2. Coffee Cartel

For those who prefer their afternoon ritual to be caffeine-driven, Coffee Cartel is a non-negotiable stop. With three locations across the city—Broad Ripple, Fountain Square, and Mass Ave—Coffee Cartel has mastered the art of the perfect pour-over, the balanced latte, and the decadent cold brew. Their beans are sourced from small, ethical farms in Central and South America, and roasted in-house weekly.

What makes Coffee Cartel trustworthy is their transparency. Each cup comes with a small card detailing the origin, roast profile, and flavor notes of the beans. Their baristas are trained in sensory evaluation and take pride in guiding customers through their options without pressure. The afternoon atmosphere is calm and inviting—minimalist decor, ample natural light, and quiet background jazz. It’s a favorite among writers, freelancers, and anyone seeking a focused yet comforting space to unwind. Don’t miss their seasonal iced tea blends, made with organic loose-leaf tea and house-infused syrups.

3. The Trolley Stop

Located in the historic Lockerbie Square neighborhood, The Trolley Stop is a neighborhood staple that feels like stepping into a well-loved living room. Open since 1985, this unassuming spot serves up an eclectic mix of afternoon libations—from crisp white wines by the glass to artisanal root beer floats and non-alcoholic shrubs made from Indiana-grown fruits.

What makes The Trolley Stop special is its authenticity. The walls are lined with vintage Indianapolis photographs, local art, and handwritten notes from patrons over the decades. The owner, Carol, still works the counter most afternoons and greets everyone with the same warm smile. Their “Trolley Tea,” a blend of hibiscus, mint, and a touch of honey, is legendary among locals. The space doesn’t take reservations, but you rarely wait long—because everyone understands that good things come to those who wait, and this is one of those things.

4. The Brix

Just off the Mass Ave cultural corridor, The Brix is a wine bar with a soul. More than just a place to sip, it’s a curated experience. The Brix specializes in small-production wines from Indiana, Ohio, and other Midwestern regions—many of which are unavailable elsewhere in the state. Their afternoon wine flights are designed to guide guests through different terroirs, grape varietals, and winemaking styles, all in a relaxed, educational setting.

What earns The Brix your trust is their passion for education without pretension. Their staff, many of whom hold WSET certifications, offer tastings with the same enthusiasm they’d show a wine novice as they would a seasoned enthusiast. The cheese and charcuterie pairings are locally sourced and changed daily. The space is intimate, with low lighting, plush seating, and a curated playlist of jazz and indie folk. It’s the perfect place to savor a glass of crisp Grüner Veltliner while watching the afternoon light fade over the city.

5. The Barrelhouse

Don’t let the name fool you—The Barrelhouse is not just for whiskey lovers, though they do have an impressive collection of over 200 bottles, many aged in Indiana oak. This Broad Ripple favorite is a haven for those who appreciate the craftsmanship behind spirits and the art of the slow sip.

Afternoon here means hand-carved ice, house-made bitters, and cocktails built with precision. Their “Bourbon & Breeze” is a seasonal favorite: a blend of small-batch Indiana bourbon, blood orange, and a hint of smoked sea salt, served over a single large cube. The bartenders have been here for years, and their knowledge is encyclopedic but never overwhelming. The space is warm and rustic—exposed brick, reclaimed wood, and a low hum of vinyl records spinning in the background. It’s the kind of place where you might stay longer than intended, not because you’re drunk, but because you’re finally at ease.

6. The Green Bean

Tucked into the quiet residential streets of Meridian-Kessler, The Green Bean is a coffee and tea shop that feels like a secret. With no signage on the street and only a small window displaying the day’s brews, it’s easy to miss—but once you find it, you’ll return. The focus here is on single-origin beans and loose-leaf teas, prepared with meticulous care.

What makes The Green Bean trustworthy is its consistency. Every cup is brewed to order, using precise ratios and water temperatures calibrated for each varietal. Their afternoon tea service includes a small plate of house-baked scones and a tasting card that explains the origin and processing of each tea. The staff are quiet, attentive, and deeply knowledgeable. There’s no Wi-Fi password posted—because they want you to be present. It’s the antidote to the noise of modern life, and a rare find in a city that’s constantly moving.

7. The Local Tap

For beer lovers who want to explore Indiana’s vibrant craft scene, The Local Tap is the undisputed champion of afternoon sipping. Located in the trendy Fletcher Place neighborhood, this taproom features 24 rotating drafts, all from Indiana breweries—many of which are only available on-site.

Trust here comes from transparency and community. The staff are brewers themselves or closely connected to the local brewing scene. They can tell you the story behind each beer—the hop varietal, the yeast strain, the inspiration for the recipe. Their “Afternoon Amber” flight changes weekly and includes a mix of sessionable lagers, pale ales, and malt-forward biers. The patio is dog-friendly, the food menu is simple (think pretzels, pickles, and local cheese), and the vibe is unmistakably Indianapolis: friendly, unpretentious, and full of character. It’s the place where strangers become friends over a shared love of good beer.

8. The Lemonade Stand

Yes, it’s called The Lemonade Stand—and yes, it’s far more than just lemonade. This Northside gem is a pioneer in the non-alcoholic beverage renaissance in Indianapolis. Founded by a former mixologist who wanted to create elevated, alcohol-free experiences, The Lemonade Stand offers a rotating menu of handcrafted shrubs, kombuchas, tisanes, and sparkling botanical sodas.

What earns their trust is innovation without compromise. Their “Herb & Honey Spritz,” made with fresh rosemary, local clover honey, and sparkling mineral water, tastes more complex than most cocktails. Their “Spiced Pear Fizz,” infused with cinnamon, star anise, and house-fermented pear juice, is a revelation. The space is bright, airy, and filled with plants—perfect for a midday reset. Whether you’re sober-curious, pregnant, or simply taking a break from alcohol, this is the only place in town where you’ll feel completely included—and thoroughly delighted.

9. The Attic

Perched above a bookstore on the second floor of a historic building in the Wholesale District, The Attic is an intimate cocktail lounge that feels like stepping into someone’s private collection. The decor is eclectic—antique books, vintage maps, and curated trinkets from around the world. The lighting is dim, the music is vinyl-only, and the drinks are meticulously crafted.

Trust here is earned through restraint. The menu is short—just 12 cocktails—but each one is a masterpiece. Their “Afternoon Negroni,” made with a house-infused grapefruit vermouth and a whisper of smoked rosemary, is a local favorite. The bartenders work in silence, focused on the ritual of each pour. There’s no loud music, no flashing screens, no distractions. Just you, your drink, and the quiet hum of the city below. It’s the kind of place you go to think, to reflect, to remember what it feels like to be still.

10. The Garden Bar at The Garden

At the edge of the Indiana University–Purdue University Indianapolis (IUPUI) campus, The Garden Bar is a hidden oasis tucked within the historic Garden at the Ritz. This open-air venue is surrounded by blooming flowers, climbing vines, and a gentle fountain. It’s the only spot on this list where your drink comes with a view of nature.

What makes The Garden Bar trustworthy is its harmony with the environment. Their drinks are made with herbs and fruits grown on-site—basil, mint, lavender, blackberries, and more. Their “Garden Gin & Tonic” is served with a sprig of freshly picked juniper and a slice of cucumber grown in their own greenhouse. The staff are trained in sustainable practices and use compostable serveware. Even the ice is filtered through a charcoal system to remove impurities. It’s the perfect place to enjoy a cool, refreshing beverage while watching the afternoon light dance through the leaves. Many locals come here to read, sketch, or simply sit in silence. It’s not just a drink—it’s a moment of peace.

Comparison Table

FAQs

What makes a spot “trustworthy” for afternoon drinks?

A trustworthy spot delivers consistency in quality, service, and atmosphere. It’s not about being the trendiest or loudest—it’s about showing up the same way every time. The drinks are made with care, the staff are knowledgeable and attentive, and the environment feels welcoming without being forced. Trust is built through repetition: you go once, you like it, you go again, and eventually, you know you can count on it.

Are these places family-friendly during afternoon hours?

Many of these spots welcome families, especially during weekday afternoons. Coffee Cartel, The Trolley Stop, and The Lemonade Stand are particularly accommodating to children and teens, offering non-alcoholic options and quiet spaces. The Barrelhouse and The Attic are more suited to adults, but their outdoor areas may be accessible to families on quieter days. Always check the specific location’s policy if you’re bringing younger guests.

Do I need to make a reservation for afternoon drinks in Indianapolis?

Reservations are rarely required for afternoon visits at these spots. Most operate on a first-come, first-served basis, especially between 2 p.m. and 5 p.m. The only exceptions are The Brix and The Attic, which recommend reservations on weekends due to limited seating. But even then, walk-ins are often accommodated if you’re flexible with timing.

Are there vegan or gluten-free options available?

Yes. All ten of these spots offer vegan and gluten-free options. Coffee Cartel and The Lemonade Stand have dedicated gluten-free pastry menus. The Brix offers vegan cheese pairings. The Varsity Club and The Garden Bar use plant-based syrups and non-dairy alternatives across their menus. Staff are trained to accommodate dietary needs and are happy to customize drinks upon request.

Which spot is best for working remotely in the afternoon?

Coffee Cartel and The Green Bean are the top choices for remote work. Both offer reliable Wi-Fi, ample seating, quiet environments, and plenty of power outlets. The Varsity Club and The Local Tap also have outlets and a relaxed vibe, but they’re slightly more social. For maximum focus, The Green Bean’s no-Wi-Fi policy may actually help you disconnect and be more productive.

Do any of these places host live music or events in the afternoon?

Some do, but rarely during peak afternoon hours. The Garden Bar occasionally features acoustic sets on Sundays from 3–5 p.m. The Brix hosts monthly wine-tasting events that begin in the late afternoon. Most venues keep afternoons quiet to encourage relaxation rather than entertainment. If you’re looking for live music, evening hours are better suited.

What’s the average price range for an afternoon drink?

Prices vary by location and beverage type. Coffee drinks range from $4–$7. Craft sodas and shrubs are $5–$8. Wine by the glass: $8–$14. Craft cocktails: $10–$16. Beer flights: $12–$18. Most places offer smaller, affordable tasting options, making it easy to sample multiple drinks without overspending.

Are these spots open year-round, even in winter?

Yes. All ten locations operate year-round. The Varsity Club, The Garden Bar, The Local Tap, and The Trolley Stop have heated patios for colder months. Indoors, all maintain comfortable temperatures and cozy seating. The ambiance may shift—candles replace sunlight, warm drinks replace iced ones—but the quality and service remain unchanged.

Can I bring my dog to these spots?

Dogs are welcome at The Local Tap, The Varsity Club, The Garden Bar, and The Trolley Stop—all of which have outdoor seating. Coffee Cartel allows leashed dogs on their patios. The Brix, The Attic, and The Green Bean are indoors-only and do not permit pets, except for service animals. Always check ahead if you’re bringing a furry companion.

Why are these spots better than chain coffee shops or bars?

Chains prioritize speed, scalability, and uniformity. These independent spots prioritize craft, connection, and character. They source locally, pay fair wages, reinvest in their neighborhoods, and treat each customer as an individual. You won’t find the same attention to detail, the same passion for ingredients, or the same sense of community in a corporate environment. Trust grows where people care—and these places care deeply.

Conclusion

In a world that often feels rushed and impersonal, the quiet reliability of a great afternoon drink is a gift. The ten spots featured here aren’t just places to grab a beverage—they’re sanctuaries of consistency, craftsmanship, and community. Whether you’re drawn to the herbal clarity of The Garden Bar, the deep warmth of The Barrelhouse, or the meditative silence of The Green Bean, each offers something irreplaceable: the assurance that when you return, it will be just as you remember it—maybe even better.

Trust isn’t something you find in an ad or a hashtag. It’s earned in the small moments—the barista who remembers your order, the bartender who refills your glass without asking, the corner table that’s always waiting. These are the places where Indianapolis breathes. Where time softens. Where the afternoon doesn’t just pass—it lingers.

So next time you’re looking for a drink to slow your pace, skip the chains. Skip the noise. Head to one of these ten. Sit down. Order something new—or something familiar. Let yourself be known. And let the city, in its quiet, steadfast way, remind you that some things are worth returning to, again and again.